How Stepping Aside Beat Holding On

Hey trader,

Cash is a position, and my sideline rule tells me when going to cash makes sense in a bear market. I don’t need to call the top or bottom.

Advisors say hold on because the market always recovers, and dip buyers wait for the bounce. Don’t get me wrong, both can work.

I care just as much about how long you sit underwater.

I’ll show you how one monthly chart and a support break move me to cash.

Getting out is only half the rule. Knowing when to step back in makes a useful idea complete.

I ran the numbers for the room Tuesday. You start with $150,000 in a retirement account in 2007, step aside when support breaks and buy back at $90.

That’s 1,666 shares, worth about $250,000 once the old high clears in 2013. Holding on only gets you back to $150,000.

Let’s start with why going to cash doesn’t scare me, then get to the exit and the way back in.

Why Going To Cash Doesn’t Scare Me

Every trade swaps one thing for another.

Sell a stock, and you’ve bought dollars with it. That’s why I call cash an unleveraged long dollar.

Going to cash means you own dollars outright, with no borrowed money behind them.

Don Kaufman pointed out Thursday that retail traders have a choice professionals don’t. You can go to cash.

I told the room Tuesday that going to cash is nothing to be scared about. Neither is a bear market.

I pushed back Monday on fear-mongering about power outages on the 17th. The most prepping I’ve done is buying flashlight batteries, because I sometimes walk the dog at night.

I told the room on the 17th that our power was still on, then pulled up 2007.

I owned a data center in 2000, and my team stayed up all night watching our servers. It was a big nothing burger.

I know some of you think Don and I are perma bears. We’re not.

The market has to breathe in and breathe out.

Recessions used to come every four years, and bank interventions stretched that to every eight. We’ve just had the biggest bull run in history, so a reset isn’t a bad thing.

The data doesn’t tell me to panic yet, either. Job growth has slowed way down without looking like a recession, and the last GDP reading was positive.

Going To Cash When Support Breaks

Support is a price area where buyers have stepped in before.

A monthly chart gives each candle a full month of trading. I use it for this call.

Don made the same case Thursday, telling the room to pull up monthly charts instead of daily ones.

My exit is simple. I step to the sidelines by going to cash when price breaks through support.

I’m not picking the top before going to cash, and I don’t need to.

I’m not even counting profits from the drop here, just stepping out and stepping back in.

The chart I showed the room Tuesday already has a big monthly sell-off on it. I told the room it could become something bigger.

The $150,000 account in my example steps aside when support breaks in 2007. I kept the numbers round to make the math easy.

It’s an illustration, so there’s no fill or result to report.

Let A Month Of Higher Closes Bring You Back

I don’t buy while the market keeps breaking down. I wait for it to reverse and give me a full month of higher closes.

A close is the last price of a candle, so a monthly close shows where price finished the month.

Waiting for that proof after going to cash costs me the bottom. The account in my example buys back at $90, which isn’t the low.

Corey Rosenbloom buys the bounces when the chart tells him he can, and that works. I’d just hold off while price keeps breaking through a downtrend.

You might take profits on short trades, skip trading or wait for a low-risk entry to go bullish. I told the room none of those are wrong answers.

Waiting for a month of higher closes costs me the bottom and keeps me from buying a falling market.

Put The Sideline Rule To Work

My example starts with 1,000 shares at $150, or $150,000. Stepping aside and buying back at $90 leaves you with 1,666 shares, 666 more than you started with.

Those shares come to $249,900 when price clears the old high in 2013. Buy-and-hold just gets back to $150,000.

Going to cash and coming back finishes about $100,000 ahead, roughly 67% on the same starting money.

I didn’t count shorts, puts or call verticals on the way down. Trading those could push the total even higher.

Riding out a 30%, 50% or 60% correction probably isn’t the right answer.

Here’s how I’d put the sideline rule on your own chart:

  1. Pull up a monthly chart. Mark the support level where buyers stepped in before.
  2. Step to cash on the break. Treat going to cash as taking a position, an unleveraged long dollar.
  3. Wait for a full month of higher closes. Hold off while price keeps breaking down.
  4. Skip the top and bottom calls. You don’t need either one for the rule to work.

That’s my line, and it doesn’t have to be yours.

Cash is a position, and a break of support tells me when to take it.

Step aside when support breaks, and let a full month of higher closes bring you back.

Blake Young
Senior Market Strategist, TheoTRADE

More from TheoTrade

My $50,000 Lesson You Can Skip

How Stepping Aside Beat Holding On

What to Do During a Global Margin Call

Old-School Levels NVIDIA Still Respected

Why Your Priciest Stocks Fall First

Why Apple Must Fall First


Most Recent

My $50,000 Lesson You Can Skip
How Stepping Aside Beat Holding On
What to Do During a Global Margin Call
Old-School Levels NVIDIA Still Respected
Why Your Priciest Stocks Fall First

Get educational market insights sent right to your inbox.

As Seen In