Why Your Priciest Stocks Fall First

Hey Trader,

Valuation is a put option. A cheap stock holds up better during multiple compression.

Multiple compression means the market pays less for every $1 of earnings. Rising rates and slowing earnings are driving it now.

Sellers go after the priciest stocks first.

You probably lean on the chart or hide in big names that feel safe.

Don’t get me wrong. Charts matter.

Those companies make big money. Yet neither one tells you what you’re paying.

I’ll show you how I check that with the P/E ratio. You only need a calculator and four quarters of earnings.

The P/E only gets you halfway. You also have to read it against its peers.

My $108,000 account lost $1,200 over three days while the S&P 500 fell 300 points. One futures contract on the index would’ve lost $15,000.

Everything I own has a low multiple.

Let’s start with how multiple compression works. Then I’ll show you the check behind every Genesis COG trade.

How Multiple Compression Works

A multiple is the price you pay for every $1 a company earns. Wall Street calls it the P/E.

Declining earnings and rising interest rates set off multiple compression. Investors start paying less for that same $1.

Bull markets need falling rates and faster growth. Stocks are pricing in a slowdown while bond yields price in inflation.

I call that a bad combo. The Fed’s latest minutes show almost every official expects more rate hikes.

The 30-year Treasury pays about 5.5%. A growth stock with no dividend pays you nothing while you wait.

Earnings beats are slowing to a crawl. Sellers are spreading multiple compression across the whole market.

Jeffrey Gundlach won’t consider the S&P 500 until its P/E falls below 15. The bond king is holding about 30% in stocks.

I agree with him. A 15 multiple would be the buy of the century.

Why Multiple Compression Hits The Priciest Stocks First

The higher the multiple, the harder multiple compression hits the stock.

A multiple of 40 gets me out of a stock. I stay calm at 6x because that multiple works as a floor.

Nvidia sat at 40x when multiple compression started hitting it. It’s already broken.

Drug stocks proved it again this week. Merck was down $4.75 on Wednesday when it ran out of buyers.

Bristol Myers broke too. GlaxoSmithKline (GSK), the cheapest of the group at about 10x, is down only a fraction.

I own GlaxoSmithKline because it’s cheap.

I’d lighten up on Eli Lilly first. It added $269 billion in market value since Oct. 6.

Only Apple added more. I have Lilly at 46x earnings, while its peers trade at 10x to 12x.

I know Lilly is making big money. I’d still fire you if you worked for me and paid 46x for it.

I think it’s the one stock that could break this market.

Why A Low Multiple Works Like A Put

A put option gains value when a stock falls. It works like insurance on the shares you own.

A low multiple does the same job during multiple compression. It limits how far a stock can fall.

Each point on an S&P 500 futures contract is worth $50. That 300-point drop cost $15,000 on one contract.

I kept my loss to $1,200 with three habits.

I’m hedged. No position tops 4%.

Every stock I own also carries a low multiple.

Sellers hit the market for a fifth straight day on Thursday. One futures contract was down $5,000 at one point.

I was down $300 on my $108,000 account.

I didn’t always trade this way. I was Mr. Momentum 20 years ago.

I was up 30% one year and lost 30% the next. I blew my accounts out.

I’ve made more mistakes over 38 years than all of you combined.

Valuation is a put option. Everything I buy starts with it.

The Check Behind Every Genesis COG Trade

I run three steps to gauge multiple compression risk before I buy:

  1. Add up four quarters. Total the last four quarters of earnings. Divide that into the share price.
  2. Read it against the peers. Check what similar companies trade for.
  3. Let the chart pick the day. I don’t buy on the way down, no matter how cheap.

Williams-Sonoma is a $230 stock. Its last four quarters add up to close to $10.

That’s about 22x earnings. I won’t pay that with housing in a bear market.

That bear market could drag it into multiple compression.

Marvell came out at 45x on a calculator I borrowed from my daughter. The semiconductor I bought that day trades at 11x.

I like my chances of multiple expansion better.

I track about 40 bank stocks. Only Wells Fargo trades cheaper than U.S. Bancorp, the one I own.

The chart only tells me when. Value comes first.

Stuff that’s cheap always comes back.

Every Genesis COG trade follows that order.

The model picks the timing only after the value checks out. It never buys in a downward channel.

I’m holding 55% cash right now. I won’t force a trade to put it to work.

I walk through every position live on Tuesdays, long and short. The Thursday update starts with my shorts.

You’ll see what I own, what I paid and the multiple behind each one.

Your survival is everything to me. Come see exactly how I’m positioned for the next leg of multiple compression.

Professor Jeffrey Bierman
Creator of the Genesis COG System

More from TheoTrade

My $50,000 Lesson You Can Skip

How Stepping Aside Beat Holding On

What to Do During a Global Margin Call

Old-School Levels NVIDIA Still Respected

Why Your Priciest Stocks Fall First

Why Apple Must Fall First


Most Recent

My $50,000 Lesson You Can Skip
How Stepping Aside Beat Holding On
What to Do During a Global Margin Call
Old-School Levels NVIDIA Still Respected
Why Your Priciest Stocks Fall First

Get educational market insights sent right to your inbox.

As Seen In